Summary: Hospital charges for the same services can vary greatly from hospital to hospital. The Department of Health and
Human Services(HHS) and the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare (CMS) have created a database making some of these charges available to the public.
Hospital charges are currently like a dart board. Throw the dart and see what you will pay. The variation goes beyond differences in location such as a rural hospital in Minnesota as compared to a healthcare system in New York City. You would expect to see a difference just based on the cost of living between these two areas.
Below are some examples of just how much variation there is:
- Joint replacement in Ada Oklahoma $5,300
- Joint replacement in Monterey Park California $223,000
- Joint replacement Sky Ridge Medical Center in Lone Tree $84,000
- Joint replacement Denver Health $46,000
- Lung blood clot treatment Beth Israel New York City $51,580
- Lung blood clot treatment NYU Hospital Center $29,869
- Lung blood clot treatment Mayo Clinic Minnesota $16,861
- Simple Pneumonia Surburban Hospital Bethesda Maryland $5,284
- Simple Pneumonia Hahnemann University Hospital Philadelphia $79,365
Part of President Obama’s Healthcare Reform is to provide more transparent. As such HHS and CMS have created a database to make some of
this information available to the public. This information is good to have but will not really be an apples to apples comparison. Factors which may not be obtained from the data include variations in demographics and the risk levels of the particular population. This can serve as more of a ballpark figure. In the examples listed above, all things being equal, where would you choose to have these procedures done?
The other important thing to note is these are “charges”. This is basically the initial offer. These rates are negotiated down through discounts with insurance companies and Medicare. So, these may not be what the patient would truly pay. There is also room for negotiation with those that are uninsured.
It will be interesting to see how hospitals respond and how they will rationalize the charges they have set as compared to their competitors. There will be quite a lot of scrambling going on.
What are your thoughts on these wide variations in charges for the same procedure? Why do they vary even within the same city which would have similar populations? Will making some of these charges available to the public help or will they cause more confusion?
About BHM Healthcare Solutions
BHM is a healthcare management consulting firm whose specialty is optimizing profitability while improving care in a variety of health care
settings. BHM has worked both nationally and internationally with managed care organizations, providers, hospitals, and insurers. In addition to this BHM offers a wide breadth of services ranging including managed care consulting, strategic planning and organizational analysis, accreditation consulting, healthcare financial analysis, physician advisor/peer review, and organizational development.
Contact Us : results@bhmpc.com, 1-888-831-1171
Follow us on Facebook:

expansion.
coverage options? Will there be an influx of newly eligible consumers rushing to setup doctor visits? Will there be a significant increase in healthcare spending? Will better data be available in terms of diagnosis and treatment of certain health issues?
will be an influx of Americans taking advantage of their newly eligible status? Do you think the paperwork required will preclude many in this group from participating?
excess of $250,000. The income levels which were affected were singles earning in excess of $400,000 and families in excess of $450,000. It now appears that other levels of income will be affected with tax hikes as inflation measures are being examined. Undoubtedly, tax increases are coming which will affect most if not all Americans either directly or indirectly.
of trust and loyalty and unity among Americans.
state, and local legislation, and paradigm shifts caused by reform. What can providers and hospital organizations do to improve their profitability? How does an organization begin to recognize and implement changes to positively affect the bottom line?
and how to code and document. This is going to be especially important when ICD-10 is implemented. Those billing for ICD-9 codes after a certain point will automatically have their claims denied. It is of utmost importance to make sure the organization is fully versed and current on all billing and coding protocols and standards in order to receive the maximum reimbursement allowed, and the appropriate reimbursement that most accurately reflects actual services provided. Coding is changing constantly and the organization needs to adapt to and adhere to these changes in order to receive the maximum reimbursement. Special considerations when coding include:
How much can we charge for the service? What is the service reimbursement in our primary contracts established as? This is the ratio between volume and price. Do you know what the ROI needs to be to be profitable? Drilling down to the cost per service provides an opportunity for apples to apples comparisons to determine inefficiencies and target areas to improve.
may need additional assistance.

ACOs must be accredited. Currently only NCQA offers ACO accreditation. Look for details in the future to see if any of the other national accreditation organizations begin to offer this type of accreditation as well.
disclosure of transfers in value by manufacturers of medical devices and drugs.



Summary: What can we expect in 2013 in terms of Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs)? Where are we headed? What considerations need to be taken into account?
turning point for health care and the focus on the patient.
Americans. However, the ripple effects of the sequestration (to Medicare patients undergoing cancer treatments) are in direct contrast to these goals and principles.
covered by Medicare who are treated in clinics. Medicare cuts were issued as 2% across the board and primarily affect Part B and Part D. Chemotherapy treatments are very costly. The Medicare cuts have created the ripple effect of cancer treatments in clinics too costly for the clinics to remain profitable.